User talk:Ca307/Mod1:81036pba

Comments

cyclopentadiene: Good results. Regarding kinetic control, perhaps a diagram showing the energy vs reaction coordinate for the two types would help? Good discussion.

Prolinol. I wonder why the energy of conformation 4 is so high? Ah, I have just spotted why thanks to Jmol. Take a close look and see if you too can spot why its so strange! Did you try any other method (PM6 for example) on this problem? Good explanations, ie with Mg its attraction, with aniline its repulsions!

Taxol: Excellent set of results. Many students do not investigate both chair and twist boat, just the one. Nice concise discussion

Carbene: Good orbitals, nice explanations. I agree, R=BRH2 is complex, and the orbital picture does not always end up giving simple pictures.

Project: Excellent results, and beautiful, concise discussion. Well done!!