Talk:Carolynmodule1

cyclopentadiene: Good results, excellent discussion

Prolinol. You write "when the carbonyl oxygen is orientated above the plane of the pyridial ring" but you do not define what "up" is, nor is the up-ness quantified (10 degrees, 20, 30?) Same goes for 7, ie by how much does the carbonyl point down (~45 degrees?) Good discussion

Taxol: Your energy for 9 is high. You do not provide a 3D model, so I can only suspect that this is due to your having located a twist boat rather than chair conformation for the rhs ring. Good discussion

Chlorodiene: You analyzed the MOs extensively, and probably there was no need for quite so much discussion here! But you got it all pretty much correct! Vibrations again well done

Project: Superb. Well done!