Talk:BBC1
Comments:
cyclopentadiene: Good results, and discussion. could have expanded upon kinetic vs thermodynamic control. What of the lower bending energy for 4?
Prolinol. Good results. Could make a little more in the discussion about the reasons being attraction (of Mg) vs repulsions of amine.
Taxol. Your results for 9 are high, and that is because your geometry shows a twist boat. A Chair is much lower for 9. 10 is fine though. Good discussion.
Carbene: Good orbitals. Not sure the diagrams labelled syn and anti stretch add much (the vibration needs to have larger visible vectors to illustrate the point; I could hardly see them. It is possible to animate in Jmol! Interesting result for BH2!
Project. Reactant modelling. Best not done with mechanics, as this cannot model any electronic effects? Excellent overall, with some interesting results for the 13C and 1H spectra. Well done.