Comments

Cyclopentadiene

Excellent discussion of endo, exo and hydrogenation - well done!!

Taxol

Correct values. Would have been good to include all the different energy values in the table so we can see all the contributions.

Very interesting and thorough discussion :)

NMR

For both, it would have been nice to include the spectra in your report. However, your figures and analysis were so good I'll let it go!! Good to see some stats and different data presentation.

Epoxide

Crystal structure

Excellent! Great discussion. Good figures and loads of interesting information.

NMR

Good. Some suggestions for the differences should have been included rather than just stating they're there.

Rotations

Good! Don't put too much faith in the lit values though.

ECD

OK to do and include, but you haven't discussed what it shows. In this case, including it is irrelevant!

TS

Good table and a great discussion

QTAIM and NCI

Good

Suggestion

Good, but you were told to find ORP>+500!

Overall

An excellent report - well done!