View source for User talk:Aln09

= Comments =

== Cyclopentadiene ==

Values are all correct. Great discussion – well done!

== Taxol ==
Found all conformations, correct calculations and values.

Could have more discussion around olefins and hydrogen interactions

=== NMR ===

1H NMR – Good – a more in depth discussion of what you can see and the final assignment would have been nice but otherwise all correct

13C NMR- Not here 
== Epoxide ==

=== Crystal structure ===
Great – you found the correct structures and good discussion
=== NMR ===

Excellent discussion.  Minor point – but it would be nice to see the NMRs and structures in the report.

=== Rotations  ===

Could look at what Shi/Jacobsen report? Otherwise good method and calculations are correct. Excellent and very thorough discussion!

No discussion of VCD/ECD

=== TS ===

Great.  

=== QTAIM and NCI ===

Nicely done

=== Suggestion ===

None provided